Hodgson has his work cut out at Liverpool

Roy HodgsonLast night’s 3-0 defeat to Manchester City underlined just how far Liverpool have fallen and new manager Roy Hodgson now knows the size of the task he has taken on.

Finishing seventh in the Premier League last year was viewed by many as an anomaly, a blip that signalled the end of Rafa Benitez’s reign. The truth is, despite the presence of Steven Gerrard and Fernando Torres, that is as good as this Liverpool team is.

Much of the blame for Liverpool’s decline will be laid at the door of Hicks and Gillett, the club’s American owners. Boardroom unrest, mounting debt, internal squabbling…it all affects the players on the pitch, it is said.

Well, sorry, I don’t buy that. Not getting paid, like happened at Portsmouth, will affect a player. Power struggles between Americans at board meetings simply won’t. So no, I do not accept that boardroom turmoil affects what happens on the pitch. It will affect the ability of the manager to add to and strengthen his squad but that’s it.

In Liverpool’s case, I really don’t think that has happened yet anyway. Certainly Benitez had enough money to spend to attract the likes of Torres, Mascherano and Aquilani. Hodgson, on the other hand, IS likely to find his hands tied in the transfer market, loosely at least. Fortunately for Liverpool, he’s well used to that.

No, Liverpool’s fall from the (near) top can be laid squarely at the door of Rafa Benitez and a squad that is well below the quality required to challenge for or in Europe. Benitez is gone now so there is very little point talking about what he did at the club, except to say his signings, like many managers at Anfield before him, simply aren’t good enough.

Gerrard, Torres and Mascherano aside, there is not one player at Liverpool that last season’s top three of Chelsea, Manchester United and Arsenal would want in their squads. Carragher is usually mentioned at this point – but I don’t believe Carragher would be half the player he is at any other club. He loves Liverpool, that’s why he performs as he does for them.

Mascherano, it seems, will soon be gone, further weakening the team. Torres is short of fitness and maybe desire. Gerrard is suffering from the lack of quality around him.

Let’s be honest, the overall performance in last night’s game was as bad, if not worse, as any from last season. Hodgson’s decision to play 4-4-2 did not help and he will have to review how he gets the best out of this team and Gerrard and Torres in particular. Hodgson, basically, needs time.

Not only to assess what he has, which is very little, but also to find the formula for success with it. Given time, I’m confident he will do it. I’m NOT confident he will get the time. And that will be down to the boardroom and what happens there. New owners might signal a new manager, while the continued involvement of Hicks and Gillett will only undermine Hodgson in terms of available money.

These are dark days for Liverpool and their supporters and a reassessment of expectation is required. Forget the top four and Champions League football. It’s not possible with this team. My probably unwelcome advice to the supporters is to accept that for now, Europa League football is the best they can expect while the manager rebuilds the club, the team and the football played from the bottom up.

Liverpool fans will have heard that before though. Benitez had a five year plan and it didn’t work. Hodgson needs a similar amount of time. Patience, I imagine, is in short supply in the Kop. Nevertheless, it’s what is required, because finishing higher than seventh year looks to be beyond them at the moment.

It’s the players that have to step up now. I don’t believe they can or want to, Carragher, Gerrard and Torres aside. Am I being too critical? Let me know in the comments!

Liverpool’s managerial hunt begins

Kenny Dalglish

Destined for the Anfield hotseat whether he likes it or not?

Now that Rafa Benitez has fled for pastures much greener (likely to be European champions Inter Milan), Liverpool are left with the unenviable task of finding a manager to restore their former glory.

The problem they have, however, is that they are no longer such an attractive proposition to many managers, crippled as they are by debt and with growing unrest in the dressing room following Benitez’s departure.

Speculation already surrounds the future of Stephen Gerrard, wanted by Jose Mourinho at Real Madrid, Fernando Torres, a reported target for Chelsea and Manchester City, Yossi Benayoun has issued a (fanciful) come and get me plea to Chelsea and Argentinian mercenary Javier Mascherano also looks set to leave to the highest bidder.

None of this is going to be particularly appealing to any prospective manager looking to further his career and add the famous Liverpool name to his CV.

The real problem though is the £351 million of debt the club’s American owners have managed to accrue. Rebuilding a team capable of winning the Premier League – surely the minimum the supporters expect still – with no funds will be impossible. Persuading the likes of Torres and Gerrard to stay will be only slightly more possible.

To do that Liverpool managing director Christian Purslow and former boss and Anfield legend Kenny Dalglish – the men charged with finding a replacement – must attract a big name capable of convincing the big name players that he is the man to put the club back in contention for honours.

The lack of Champions League football next season is also a negative for players and possible managers as well. In short, the future for Liverpool looks bleak.

Let’s leave the playing staff to one side, however, and look at the names being touted around for the now hotter than ever Anfield hotseat.

First of all there is Kenny Dalglish himself. He’s already managed the club to success and is, of course, popular with the supporters. He has received backing from former players Jamie Redknapp and Bruce Grobbelaar. It would be a step backwards and I’m not sure Dalglish would be that interested. He is, presumably, being very well paid to ‘consult’ on Benitez’s replacement so taking the job himself might not be what he wants.

Outside pressure may convince him to take up the position, at least on a temporary basis until a big name manager becomes available.

One such big name is new Turkey boss Guus Hiddink. A proven manager with a long list of successes, Hiddink may have the presence to convince Liverpool’s big name players to give it another season and could have the skills to mould the current side into a more successful unit. His agent has already said the move is unlikely though and Hiddink has a history of remaining loyal to his contracts.

Martin O’Neill is a far more likely candidate. He could operate within the tight budgets that will be inflicted on the new manager, he is good with the players and he must now be looking to make a step up from Aston Villa. The only thing lacking from his CV is a big name club (unless you include Celtic – and I don’t). Liverpool would suit him perfectly.

Villa owner Randy Lerner will step in and try to convince O’Neill to stay should Liverpool make an approach and the good working relationship they have – compared to the mess that is the Anfield ownership – may swing the balance in the Birmingham club’s favour.

There is no doubt that O’Neill would seriously consider it but would ask for certain assurances. It would be up to Dalglish and Purslow to give them – if they can.

Fulham’s success in the Europa League last season has pushed Roy Hodgson’s name to the forefront of many club’s thoughts, Liverpool included. Like O’Neill, Hodgson would see Liverpool as a step up and an opportunity to further his career. The supporters may not be as happy with his appointment as one might imagine, however. Despite his glowing record with Inter Milan and Fulham and his wealth of managerial knowledge there remains a niggling doubt from the man in the street.

Fulham chairman Mohammed Al-Fayed would fight tooth and nail to keep his man, of course, but the lure of Anfield may be enough. Hodgson is unlikely to be as fazed by the club’s financial mess as O’Neill would be.

Harry Redknapp is another name that has been mentioned. This, though, is very unlikely. The Tottenham manager has Champions League football to look forward to next season, he is in the process of building a side capable of challenging for an even higher position in the Premier League than last season’s fourth place and he seems more settled than he has in a long time.

Add in the fact Harry has never managed up North and is a London boy at heart and there seems no reason why he would move to Liverpool. Except one – Redknapp covets the England job and he may feel that managing Liverpool would bring him closer to getting it once Capello has moved on. That would be one hell of a risk to take though.

Other names being linked include Bayern Munich’s Louis van Gaal, Croatia’s Slaven Bilic, Galatasary’s Frank Rijkaard and former Manchester City boss Mark Hughes. All of these would be put off by the club’s financial and ownership worries, however.

Liverpool have a difficult job convincing any prospective manager that these issues are just temporary and it seems likely that before they can attract the man they want then a new owner and more stability will have to be found at boardroom level. That means the smart money must go on Dalglish to take charge in the short term until those problems are resolved.

Right now that seems the only viable option and the club’s supporters must resign themselves to another unsuccessful season next year – and maybe for more seasons after that – and the loss of some of their favourite players too.

Liverpool FC set to lose Torres as well as Gerrard?

Various reports around that Fernando Torres may need surgery on a groin problem and could be out for up to two months. Under pressure manager Rafa Benitez, however, is prepared to put his star striker at risk and he travels to Lyon for the Champions League tie this evening despite the injury.

Already shorn of captain and talisman Gerrard, it seems a strange decision to jeopardise Torres’ immediate future as far as Sporting Fare is concerned – but then Rafa’s decision making this season hasn’t exactly been brilliant, has it.