Is Andy Carroll a future England legend…or a one cap wonder?

Andy CarrollNewcastle striker Andy Carroll will make his England debut in less than 30 minutes after a promising start to the season and in spite of a groin injury and his well documented off field discretions.

So is he a future England legend, as so many hacks, former pros and Newcastle fans have said, or will he be a one cap wonder as many cynics have suggested? In all probability he will be somewhere in between, as far better better players than he have proved to be. I give you Michael Owen and Wayne Rooney as examples. Ooh, controversial.

Most of the talk surrounding Carroll is not of his ability and potential but of his private life and how that is currently messing up his career. That’s fair enough, it’s true. Capello has offered him a lifeline and a warning, as I’m sure Chris Hughton would if he wasn’t more worried about his own future as Newcastle manager.

But what of his actual talent? He’s done well so far for Newcastle, of that there is no doubt. However, I saw Carroll play at Old Trafford and while he caused problems for Manchester United’s defence in a physical sense – and he wasn’t half sneakily dirty for one so young too – his footballing ability was left lacking.

For me, Carroll can finish. He is strong. He is tall. He is brave. That’s not bad for a striker is it. Except, apart from the finishing, he is a young Emile Heskey. And as we all know, Capello likes a Heskey.

That’s not enough at international level though. Look at Spain. No battering ram, just a supremely skilful squad. At club level Carroll, I’m sure, will do well. At international level he will prove to be a disappointment. Or he’ll prove me wrong and go on to play 100 times and score over 50 goals. But who believes that? Do you?

Capello’s defensive decisions made easy

Rio Ferdinand

To play him or not to play him? Rio Ferdinand starts anyway.

Seems to me every time an international break rolls round the media enjoy a “Who will be selected?” funfest, usually finding at least one position contentious.

Then all that speculation is proved unnecessary and pointless by withdrawals due to injuries and personal problems.

England manager Fabio Capello seems to ‘get lucky’ with this, avoiding the alleged decision through misfortune. Well, he’s done it again.

The issue, of course, surrounded the returning Rio Ferdinand and whether or not he should start ahead of the impressive Phil Jagielka. Or even alongside him in place of John Terry…

Now both players have pulled out, leaving Ferdinand an automatic starter and Capello headache free.

Still, there’s the question over the captaincy to resolve. General consensus is that Stephen Gerrard has performed the task well in the absence of the Manchester United defender and I have to agree.

However, not at any point has Ferdinand been stripped of the captaincy, therefore if he plays he wears the armband. I’m pretty sure Gerrard knows and understands this. Not that tricky a question after all, is it.

For what it’s worth, had there been no injuries to Jagielka and Terry then Ferdinand should have been left on the bench.

Not because of doubts over his fitness or form, simply because the other two have earned the right to keep their places and Rio should have to fight his way back in.

It’s as simple as that. So why can’t the media – and a succession of England managers – understand it?

Davies selection highlights lack of quality in depth

Kevin DaviesThe selection of Bolton striker Kevin Davies by Fabio Capello for the upcoming European Championship qualifier against Montenegro tells me just one thing – England lack any real quality in depth.

I’m not saying Davies doesn’t deserve his call up before any Bolton Wanderers fans get on my case, but no-one can tell me he is really international class, let alone world class.

What it does show is that in the absence of only really above average strikers like Defoe, Agbonlahor and Zamora we can only turn to a 33 year old who has spent most of his career being used as a battering ram. England’s real problem is that for all the hype and media driven reputations of certain players you can count on one hand the number of truly world class players and still have fingers to spare.

Right now only Stephen Gerrard and Wayne Rooney deserve to be considered for that category and even they aren’t managing to live up to the name. Around them are good players – not great, just good – and players with potential. Most people’s first choice England XI contains two ‘world class’ players, six good players and three kids with huge potential. That is not, and never will be, a tournament winning team.

That said and with acceptance of the above, Davies is a good short term choice by Capello given the lack of other options. Only really Newcastle’s Andy Carroll has made a case to come in with the three others mentioned injured but, as @philmcnulty so brilliantly wrote in his latest blog, “Capello has made it clear he will not indulge flavours of the month in favour of the more pragmatic selection“.

Rooney, Darren Bent and Peter Crouch are not in the same mould as Davies, they can’t play the battering ram role he has performed so admirably for years now. Capello’s former favourite for the position, Emile Heskey, has refused to come out of retirement (thank God), so Davies is the only choice.

As McNulty also pointed out in his blog, to consider Davies only a target man is to do him a disservice. He would not have lasted so long in the top flight – and played no small part in keeping Bolton there at the same time – without more than a modicum of skill. That it has often been overlooked due to his more obvious talent of harassing and occasionally battering defenders into submission is hardly surprising, but it is nevertheless there.

His strike rate in front of goal is also better than Heskey’s…in fact, when you think about it, it’s a wonder Davies is only getting is first proper call up at 33, though he has been in provisional squads in the past.

Should Montenegro prove a tough nut to crack, Davies is the ideal player to turn to. No, he won’t start the game, the honour of partnering Rooney will go to the in-form Darren Bent, and rightly so, but you can bet he’ll be ready should he be needed.

In the meantime, Capello and us supporters must accept that England and the players available for selection are just above average – and no better. It’s nothing to be ashamed of, these things are cyclical, but it will be a lot harder to become contenders if we keep deceiving ourselves that we already are.

The likes of Kevin Davies are perfectly good enough to do a job at the level we’re at and I hope Capello and the supporters give him the chance to do so.

Is it cos I is black?

It’s funny how a chat in a pub can reveal things. Like potential racism in the Football Association and in previous and present England managers…

Ali GYet that’s just what cropped up last night while my mate (@BS6651) and I were discussing England strikers while watching the game against Hungary. It might sound a little farfetched. The FA and England managers racist? Surely not? But look at the evidence…

Think of some of the decent strikers in the last 20 years and many of them are black. We thought of Ian Wright, Andy Cole, Dion Dublin, Stan Collymore and more recently Darren Bent, Gaby Agbonlahor, Carlton Cole, Bobby Zamora and Jermain Defoe. Christ, even Dalian Atkinson was mentioned, though not by me!

What do they all have in common? They score(d) goals, of course, in abundance in many cases. That – and the fact that none of them have really been given a fair chance at international level. But why?

Dalian Atkinson formed a decent partnership with Dean Saunders at Aston Villa, scoring 36 goals for the club and 86 in his career. Ok, not so brilliant but not bad, not bad at all. His international reward was one cap for the England B team.

Ian Wright is an Arsenal legend of course. 128 goals in 221 games is testament to that. His career stats read 305 goals in 596 games. That is a striker of the highest quality. Why then does he have only 33 England caps, of which only 17 were starts? Any other striker with that record would have been pushing 50+ caps and have scored more than nine international goals.

Andy Cole has suffered even more. Despite a career record of 270 goals in 621 games, including League, FA Cup and Champions League winners medals (not to mention Manchester United’s unprecedented Treble in 1999), Cole has just 15 England caps, few of them as starter, and only one goal. From 1997 to 2000 he scored more than 20 League goals three seasons running. So why, again, the lack of international reward?

Stan Collymore has a less impressive record and an even worse reputation as a man. But during his pomp he was a striker to be feared. In the League alone he scored 99 goals in 251 games throughout his career, his best period playing for Nottingham Forest and Liverpool, for whom he scored 82 goals across four seasons. Number of England caps? Just three. And no goals.

Dion Dublin is less prolific but his importance on the pitch, particularly for Aston Villa, should not be underestimated – plus he has a better record than Emile Heskey, one of Capello’s recent favourites. He still scored 183 League goals in 623 games in his career and yet has only four England caps and no goals.

In more recent times, the likes of the previously mentioned Bent, Zamora, Agbonlahor and Defoe have had impressive seasons, not least Darren Bent, but all have struggled to start for their country. Defoe has had the most success with 43 caps and 12 goals so it’s perhaps unfair to say he has suffered, though he still struggles to start games. The rest really have struggled to get picked or play.

So is it cos they is black? Are the FA and successive England managers ever so slightly racist and biased towards England’s white strikers?

No, probably not. It’s far more likely the players named have been unfortunate enough to play in the same eras as Alan Shearer, Teddy Sheringham, Michael Owen and Wayne Rooney. But still…it makes you think. Especially when you’ve had one too many watching the current side struggle to beat Hungary!

England revamped? Hardly, Fabio, hardly.

EnglandFollowing England’s hugely disappointing World Cup campaign, coach Fabio Capello promised to ring the changes and revamp England with the aim of making us more competitive on the international stage.

On Wednesday the national side takes on Hungary in their first game since South Africa and one look at the squad picked by the Italian leaves me feeling utterly underwhelmed.

It’s not a revamp, it’s a second chance saloon for players not considered good enough for the biggest stage in the world just five weeks ago. Oh, and there’s some untested kids in there, which I’m actually in favour of, though I don’t feel it’s gone far enough or that they are necessarily the right kids.

Let me breakdown the squad and give my views on why their selection is a good or bad thing.

In goal David James has suffered for his move to Bristol City and is dropped, as is Rob Green, punished presumably for his error against the USA. Only Joe Hart remains, joined by Ben Foster, who moved from Manchester United to Birmingham in the summer, and Paul Robinson…except Robinson’s response to his call up was to announce his international retirement!

Capello will have to choose another keeper then, but in Joe Hart and Ben Foster he has made good choices. Hart will get the nod on Wednesday, having played more games, but these two are the future for England and they must be picked every game. If Foster has a good season with Birmingham he will overtake Hart, who is now back at Man City but not guaranteed to start.

Third choice keeper could now be Rob Green who may well benefit from Robinson’s surprising decision. Overall though, I’m happy.

In defence, Wes Brown was picked but then followed Robinson’s lead and quit international football. I don’t really understand this decision from Wes but what’s done is done.

That leaves long standing internationals Ashley Cole, John Terry and Glen Johnson, joined by Phil Jagielka, Gary Cahill, Michael Dawson and Kieran Gibbs. I’ve no problem with the first three (though Cole will have to play better than he did in yesterday’s Community Shield) so what about the new faces?

Everton’s Phil Jagielka had a great season two years ago, but didn’t reproduce last season. He was still good, just not great. He’s worth a look, but will he get more call ups after this? I tend to doubt it unless he plays and puts in a remarkable performance.

Gary Cahill has been knocking on the England door for a while now but the fact he plays for Bolton has, in my opinion, always hampered his chances. Nevertheless, he IS worth looking at but he must get more than 10 minutes on the pitch if he’s to be considered for future squads.

Michael Dawson should have gone to the World Cup on merit, not because Rio Ferdinand got injured and I’m glad to see he’s not paid the price for England’s overall showing. Another good season for Spurs and he’ll perhaps become Terry’s permanent partner with Rio’s ability to perform at the very top in doubt thanks to injury.

Finally, Arsenal’s promising young defender Gibbs. I have only seen glimpses so it would be unfair for me to comment on his suitability, but almost everything you read about him contains high praise so it’ll be good to see him play, see how he handles the big occasion and whether or not he’s as good as everyone says. Gibbs is going to need more minutes for his club this season though, surely?

The midfield choices are, I’m sorry to say, utterly underwhelming. Apparently the inclusion of Arsenal’s Jack Wilshere can be considered a revamp. Do me a favour, Fabio. Gerrard, Barry, Lampard and Milner all retain their places. Clearly Barry has something on Capello that we don’t know about, such is the Italian’s love for him, but Milner has done nothing to suggest he should still be in the squad, while one of Gerrard and Lampard should be sacrificed for the future – as I’ve often said, it should be Lampard. I’m thoroughly disappointed by these choices.

I am, however, very pleased to see Manchester City’s Adam Johnson back in the squad and I think he should start regularly on the left for England if Joe Cole is to be dropped permanently. Get him now, let him find his feet, don’t worry about the odd poor performance and crack on with him. This is one player I will happily say is the future of England.

Ashley Young is back in and I do like him as a player but he really needs to play well now. If he can play like he does for Villa then he’s a shoe-in for the right flank. He’s a far superior player to Theo Walcott, also recalled, though I have no idea why. I wouldn’t pick Walcott ever again unless he starts playing for Arsenal regularly and actually fulfilling that supposed potential he has.

I’ve seen fast players before and if it’s all you’ve got, get lost. So come on, Theo, prove me wrong. I bet you can’t.

Then there is the aforementioned Wilshere. Again, I’ve not seen much of him (who has?) but everything you read is good so fair enough, play him. But do actually PLAY him, or what’s the point? This is what worries me about this squad and Capello.

It’s not a revamp, it’s a nod in the direction of the fans without truly committing to overhauling England from scratch. My blueprint for England’s future was far more ruthless and, of course, I believe the better option. But we’re all armchair managers, entitled to an opinion, whether it has value or not. I’m not saying mine has and know many will disagree with me. Quite rightly too, it’s why we love the game.

Back to the squad though, and on to the strikers. Wayne Rooney is picked, of course. BUILD THE TEAM AROUND HIM! There can’t be an Englishman (or woman) who would call for Rooney to be dropped with any seriousness so it’s not worth even talking about his merits. We all know what they are.

It’s the other three that baffle. Fulham’s Bobby Zamora – one good season then not considered good enough – back in. Ridiculous. Sunderland’s Darren Bent – scores goals wherever he goes and bagged plenty last season, is well worthy of a call up to be honest, so fair enough. I still doubt whether or not he’s international class, but he hasn’t really been given a fair crack yet.

Carlton Cole?! Really? Sorry, but like Andrew before him, this Cole has his qualities and at domestic level he can be one of the best, but at international level this is like picking Emile Heskey…oh, right, I see what you’ve done there, Fabio…

And yet you’ve dropped Peter Crouch, who has never let England down and has a scoring record these three would love to have. I really have lost faith in your thinking, my friend.

For all his talk, all his reputation, all his apologies, Fabio Capello has bottled it when it matters most with this squad. A thriving Under-21 team is virtually ignored, a sprinkling of unproven but promising children are included while the majority of the failed old guard retain their places. And will no doubt start ahead of uncapped and untested anyway.

So what’s the bloody point? I’ll probably watch on Wednesday, but I don’t expect to be surprised, pleased or heartened. I expect, in fact, to be bored, disappointed and disheartened.

Ever was it thus with England and their managers though, eh.

Capello returns to work to face FA board

Fabio CapelloBack from his undeserved holiday, England manager Fabio Capello faces the FA board on his return to work (assuming he decides to attend – he doesn’t have to, but he damn well should), expected to hand in his report on what happened in South Africa during the World Cup.

Smacks of the failed school child filling in his end of term report, doesn’t it. I can imagine Capello and his ‘gang’ – Franco Baldini et al – staring at their shoes, looking sheepish, in front of a long table occupied by the FA board members as they peruse his broken English report.

It’s almost demeaning.

Yet should he expect anything else? I don’t for a second lay all the blame for England’s poor tournament performance at his door. They players MUST shoulder the majority of the blame, they didn’t do themselves or their country justice. However, several of Capello’s decisions in the run up to and during the World Cup were questionable.

What I’m wondering now is what does he do between now and England’s friendly against Hungary in August?

Capello talked about freshening up the England squad with youth and exuberance. He has the chance to run the rule over our Under-19s from the 18th-30th July during the European Championships, yet reports suggest he won’t be attending. One can only assume he is sending Baldini – or should I say one hopes?

I can’t see that he has anything else to do for those 12 days, so why isn’t he going? This is England’s future and he has two years left on his contract, by which time at least some of these players could and should be pushing for a senior place. This is the ideal time to earmark those he feels will make it and follow their progress in the run up to the Euros in 2012.

It will be baffling if he doesn’t take that opportunity.

Of course, he has that tricky board meeting this afternoon first. Sky Sports are reporting that the World Cup is NOT an item on the agenda, however. Nothing like sweeping things under the carpet, eh, lads. They should be sitting down and picking apart EVERYTHING that went wrong, no matter how uncomfortable it is.

We’ve all read the reports of dressing room unrest and players falling out with one another. Surely decisions need to be taken on who was at fault for this and banish them from the squad for good, freeing up those places for youth. No matter who they are…

I laid out my blueprint for England’s future a couple of weeks ago and I stand by it. Radical action needs to be taken to start getting England back to the pinnacle of world football and it seems to me it isn’t going to happen…again.

The FA have always been stuck in the past but I thought Capello was dynamic enough to start changing that, respected enough to be allowed to do so. Seems I was wrong and he has been ground down by the sheer idiocy and resistance to change from his bosses. That’s why change is needed at the very top, not at manager level.

In the meantime, we may as well resign ourselves to overall mediocrity and the boom and bust mood England’s performances (and the media reporting of it) will create in the country.

England RISE one place in FIFA rankings

FIFA LogoFIFA have released their latest world rankings and it’s a bit of a surprise that England, despite their abysmal showing in the World Cup, have risen one place to seventh.

Yesterday FIFA announced the rankings of the 32 teams that competed in South Africa and England were placed 12th so quite how they’ve managed to climb UP the overall rankings is a mystery – but then, the FIFA way of ranking teams has always been a mystery to me, even when I’ve read up on how they do it!

Less surprising is Spain’s new ranking as the best team in the world – they are World and European champions, that’s a no-brainer! Holland have risen to second place, pushing Brazil down to third in the table, their lowest ranking in quite some time.

New Zealand have deservedly risen the most places – 24 places to 54th – after remaining the only unbeaten side in the World Cup. Uruguay rose 10 places to sixth following their fantastic campaign, while deposed world champions Italy dropped six places and out of the top 10 to 11th.

Here’s the revised top ten:

  1. Spain
  2. Holland
  3. Brazil
  4. Germany
  5. Argentina
  6. Uruguay
  7. England
  8. Portugal
  9. Egypt
  10. Chile

My Blueprint for England’s Future

Blueprint for England's futureEveryone has an opinion on the direction the FA should take with England’s future. The press, ex-players, Premier League chairmen, the man in the street. This is mine.

Firstly, and above all else, we as a nation must accept that right now, this very moment, we are not very good. Despite all our hopes, despite the quality of the Premier League and the performances therein by English players, ENGLAND are not very good.

We must accept, all of us, that the second round of the World Cup is our level, that is how good we are, that is the measure of us. Accept that then, and only then, can we look to get better. Because without doing so it doesn’t matter who is coach or who is picked, they will be so weighed down by unrealistic expectation they will never achieve better than we have now. Which is NOTHING.

Say it to yourself. England have achieved NOTHING in 44 years – and even then, with a home crowd behind behind us and seriously poor opposition until the final, we only just did enough to win our solitary trophy.

So let us abandon the idea we can compete with the likes of Brazil, Germany, Spain and Argentina and instead look to how we can start approaching their level.

Let us put a decisive, non-compromising plan in place now to target the 2014 World Cup – or even the 2016 European Championships. Certainly, let us sacrifice the 2012 Euros in favour of building a footballing foundation that will last for generations, not one competition.

This is simply not in our nature, of course. As Englishmen and women we are pre-programmed to believe we are the best, or at least up there with them. It goes against our grain to think otherwise.

That’s why the first change that has to be made is a complete restructuring and downsizing of the FA and the appointment of FOOTBALL men to the very top. Men who have the right vision to take English football out of the 1960′s and into the 21st century.

There are plenty of men around with that vision, believe it or not. Sir Trevor Brooking and Howard Wilkinson are just two. Neither fit the bill on other requirements, however.

It is they who should be given the task of guiding the direction of football in this country, backed by another man. A man who has the strength to stand up in the face of fierce criticism with the longer term in mind, a man who will not bow to the money-backed Premier League and their selfish demands, a man who will ignore the press and their ‘blame games‘ until the press realise they back the long term or don’t matter. It is here I have draw a blank, to be honest. Where do you look for THAT?

There are a few names that spring to mind, but their likelihood is almost nil. Sir Alex Ferguson would be one. Arsene Wenger another. There would likely be the xenophobic outcry at appointing a foreigner to the top job in English football but that view is outdated in my opinion.

Only then can we get that damned National Football Centre built in Burton and stop fannying about. Make that the focal point of developing truly capable coaches ready to nurture the next generation of England players, even if it takes a couple of years. I read a stat recently that numbered just over 2,000 qualified coaches in England compared to over 20,000 in Spain and Germany. Ok, the populations are different, but that’s a shocking disparity nonetheless.

I’m not just talking about the future managers and coaches of football clubs here, I include youth coaches, Sunday League coaches, kids team coaches…anyone and everyone that wants to learn. The National Football Centre should be a school for all, as logistically challenging as that may be.

Burton will begin to address that disparity I mentioned. It should also be the home of every national age group so a Team England philosophy can truly be developed (Henry Winter of the Daily Telegraph‘s idea, not mine, but I wholeheartedly agree).

Within this centre of footballing excellence those future coaches and managers should focus on developing and nurturing ball skills, flair, individuality and less on results. Kids can worry about results when they grow up, while they’re young and impressionable the only thing that should matter is improving their skills and, more importantly, having fun.

Too much emphasis is put on results in this country, you can see it at every level of the game. I’ve experienced it, playing right back for my Cub and Scout football teams with parents yelling at you that you’re out of position, you should have made that tackle, get up the field and support the winger (4-4-2 in those days you see…). The fun was very quickly taken out of playing the game.

In the squad that went to the World Cup there were only two players that play the game with the same freedom as the likes of Messi and Ronaldo – Rooney and Joe Cole. The former was hindered by the lack of support given by his team, the other barely got to play. Fear grips our players and they don’t have the balls to express themselves. This is bred into them from youth. It needs to stop.

That emphasis on how we play and not what results it achieves needs to remain right through each age group, up to and possibly including Under-21 level. I’m a firm believer that given the freedom to play as an individual (never forsaking the fact you’re part of a team of course) results will come anyway – and you will enjoy them more. Nor will you be afraid of defeat, you’ll have experienced it from a young age and realised it is not the end of the world.

What we’re talking about here is not just improving the facilities and the coaching but of changing a mindset that has become so ingrained that it cripples even our best players.

There’s your foundation for the future of the national side in this country and will represent the long term. What can be done in the medium term? Well, FIFA’s plans to limit starting line ups to six home grown payers and five foreign players is a sound one. It has its detractors, of course, not least within the Premier League and there is the thorny issue of European law to negotiate, but over time it will only benefit the national side.

The appointment of an England manager for a significant period of time with a guarantee there would be no knee-jerk reactions to results would also help. There would be no  harm in keeping Capello for that matter. Let a man mould the players he is given into a team over several years, not one qualifying period and a tournament. Sacrifice, in this case, the 2012 Euros, see how we do, enjoy what we do achieve and work on what we don’t.

Which brings us to the short term and the dismantling and rebuilding of the current England side from what is available right now. Capello himself has already listed players he would now bring in if he is given the chance to do so by the dithering Football Association.

Some I agree with, some I don’t. But those that MUST go now include, in my opinion, David James, Jamie Carragher, Ledley King, Michael Carrick, Frank Lampard and Emile Heskey. Question marks hang over John Terry and even Steven Gerrard.

What I would do right now is build a team around Wayne Rooney, one that is geared towards getting the best out of him without relying solely upon him. I’m no tactical genius but it seems to me the way to go about this is a variation on 4-5-1, as we really don’t have the players to go 4-3-3.

Let Rooney spearhead the team, supported by Gerrard (I’m not ready to ditch him yet, just get Lampard away from him). Put two defensively-minded midfielders in behind him and some pacy, flair-y wingers out wide. Rebuild the central defence and install Joe Hart for good in goal.

Name names, you cry! They are few and far between, making it difficult, I reply! But as you asked…

Ok, well, Capello has name checked most already, but Manchester City’s Adam Johnson looks ready for the left wing. Aaron Lennon deserves another chance and Villa’s Ashley Young should be given his. If Owen Hargreaves can get fit then he remains our best holding midfielder, no matter how sad that may seem and until a younger version emerges. Gareth Barry would benefit from his presence. Then there’s Arsenal’s young players, Kieran Gibbs and Jack Wilshere. Ben Foster can play second fiddle to Hart unless or until he proves the better option at Birmingham. Everton have Leighton Baines, Dan Gosling and Jack Rodwell to consider.

There are more – but we don’t know them because hardly any Premier League club can afford to take too much of a risk by playing them often. Arsenal do it sparingly, Everton by necessity and even Manchester United with their history of nurturing youth have all but stopped. I bring you back to FIFA’s six-plus-five ideas. There’s the solution to that.

If we’re all really serious about wanting a national side that can compete with the best in the world we need to do all this and more, but it will be for nought if we don’t accept – today – that we can’t and that changes need to be made, not just with football but with how we think about success and failure.

Who wants it now: England’s managerial contenders

If, as is widely expected, the Football Association toss several more million pounds Fabio Capello’s way along with his P45 and wish him well, they will then be faced with the daunting prospect of appointing his successor from a very short shortlist of possibilities.

Harry Redknapp

That list gets ever shorter as I expect the FA to return to English managers following the relative failures of the Italian and Sven Goran-Eriksson. They may not have that luxury should the English contenders rule themselves out, so we’d better look at a few of the other options as well.

On with the Englishmen first though.

Roy Hodgson: The Fulham manager’s stock is high right now following his success with the London club in European competition. He’s also a wanted man, with Liverpool wanting him to put them back on the right track. He has international experience with the United Arab Emirates, Finland and Switzerland, as well as working in Scandinavia and Italy at club level. In terms of knowledge and ability there are few to match Hodgson and he’d be a popular choice for the supporters as well. Where my doubts lie are in the strength of his personality – does he have the presence to command and, more importantly, motivate a team of England’s finest players? I just don’t know – but we’ll never know unless he’s given the chance.

Harry Redknapp: Harry seems to be the Marmite of football managers, you either love him or hate him. I love him (but I HATE Marmite). What he has done at club level with small clubs like Bournemouth, West Ham United and Portsmouth has been nothing short of genius and he has taken that to a bigger club in Tottenham and continued in the same fashion. As a motivator he is second to none, his ability to get the very best out of his players – no matter their level of ability – is proven. His career has progressed in such a way that if it doesn’t culminate in managing his country it will be a surprise. The FA, however, will have serious concerns about his baggage, not least the impending court case over alleged tax evasion. But what’s that got to do with football, I ask?

Stuart Pearce: Stuart, for so long a roaring Lion for England on the field, has become rather quieter off it, especially since he joined the international set up. The FA are clearly grooming him for the future and following his success with the Under 21s he joined Fabio Capello’s backroom team to learn from the master – though what he will have learned is a huge question mark now. Perhaps he learned more what NOT to do? Pearce is a student of the game and has a passion for England few can match. That combination could work – but is it too soon? Questions, you see, always questions.

Sam Allardyce: If Roy Hodgson’s stock has risen rapidly, Big Sam’s has dropped at roughly the same speed. His reputation, built at Bolton, actually had him line for the England job at one point but since leaving Bolton he’s struggled to make the same impact at Blackburn. They haven’t done badly – but they haven’t done brilliantly either, and Sam is now out of the frame. Yet he is a players’ manager, able, like Redknapp, to coax performances from average players. A useful skill for an England manager to have… The FA will only turn to Allardyce now if they have exhausted all other options, however.

It is not beyond the realms of possibility that the FA could look below the Premier League at English managers and coaches in the Championship. It’s unlikely, but not impossible. Who do we have down there that might be in with a shout then?

Well, there’s Steve Coppell at Bristol City for one. The former England international has all the credentials, is well respected and a good coach. There must be a question mark over his ability to handle the pressure of the big job though – he lasted just 33 days at Manchester City due to it. Nevertheless, his success with Reading in particular must count to his credit.

There are plenty of other good, if not great, English managers in the Premiership. But you just can’t see the FA going for them, likely through fear of both the unknown – they haven’t done it at the top level yet – and fear of a fans backlash. Despite everything, England fans will demand a big enough name. The logic is flawed, of course, but it’s human nature.

How, though, are English manager ever going to get that top level experience when Premiership clubs insist on appointing big name foreigners? Therein lies the problem. The topic was discussed on Radio 5Live last night and it was pointed out that the best sides at this year’s World Cup are managed by men of the same nationality – and that the clubs in those countries are managed by the same for the most part. Coincidence?

So what of the foreign options left open to the FA?

Arsene Wenger: Hugely respected at the FA and clearly a fantastic manager but an outside bet anyway, simply due to the fact Wenger is unlikely to want to manage England. He would no doubt be flattered to be considered, but would turn it down with grace. Whether or not he could get the best out of England’s players without the day to day contact he enjoys at Arsenal is a worry as well.

Martin O’Neill: Here we have a real man-manager who enjoys working with English players and nurturing them at Aston Villa. On paper he is the ideal candidate and he’d jump at the chance of the England job. He isn’t one for staying too long at a club so it gets stale too and I get the sense that might not be too far off with Villa. Another season or two? He’s definitely in with a shout, though apparently he didn’t impress in his last interview with the FA when they looked for a replacement for Eriksson. They’ll take another look though.

David Moyes: Another in with a shout due to his success with Everton on a shoe string. He can clearly motivate his men, his tactical ability is strong and he is a willing learner. Importantly, he is also good with the press. Whether he can handle the pressures of the England job is a debate to have but there’s nothing yet to suggest he couldn’t.

Would the FA consider a previous England manager? It is doubtful, but Steve McLaren has proved what a good manager he can be with FC Twente and one newspaper even touted Eriksson as an option! I’ll toss another name into the ring too – Glenn Hoddle. He had England playing the best football I have seen them play. It was a shame he was and still maybe a complete loon, but he suits international management in my mind.

If I had to pick one right now to replace Capello, however, I wouldn’t hesitate in choosing Harry Redknapp. England don’t need a tactical genius, they need a man who can motivate, handle the press and with enough brains to send his team out knowing the jobs they have to do. For me, Redknapp is it and right now he’s at the top of his game.

Where would your vote go?